It consists of a psychoanalytic study of Leonardo's life based on his paintings. According to Freud, the Virgin's garment reveals a vulture when viewed sideways. Freud claimed that this was a manifestation of a "passive homosexual" childhood fantasy that Leonardo wrote about in the Codex Atlanticus, in which he recounts being attacked as an infant in his crib by the tail of a vulture. He translated the passage thus:
Homosexuality is assuredly no advantage, but it is nothing to be ashamed of, no vice, no degradation; it cannot be classified as an illness; we consider it to be a variation of the sexual function, produced by a certain arrest of sexual development.
Many highly respectable individuals of ancient and modern times have been homosexuals, several of the greatest men among them.
Plato, Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci, etc. It is a great injustice to persecute homosexuality as a crime — and a cruelty, too. Although Freud was a maverick in theorizing, how did he come to accept homosexuality as a natural part of our sexual development?
From what I gather, everything started with the man who made this painting: The outcome of that decision was a novelette whose purpose was to expose a psychoanalytic study on Leonardo.
Freud acknowledged that this endeavor was very tentative and his findings were based on a scarcity of biographical materials. Nevertheless, he established the framework of his book on a rumination about childhood Freud leonardo essay Leonardo left in one of his notebooks.
Freud took that childhood contemplation and elaborated an artistic interpretation from it.
It seems…that I was destined to occupy myself so thoroughly with a vulture, for it comes to my mind as a very early memory that, as I was in my cradle, a vulture came down to me, opened my mouth with its tails, and stuck me many times with its tail against my lips. However, because of the over-protective and excessive love from her mother, Leonardo was subjected to too much femininity, which set the stage for his homosexuality.
But that explained only the inception process of homosexuality. Full blown homosexual behavior comes later on in life, after the child finally becomes an adult and tends to repress his love for his mother and inadvertently identifies with her. Additionally, another important factor that plays a role in becoming a homosexual is anal eroticism.
Anal eroticism comes from a fixation during the anal stage of psychosexual development. This theory about the origins of homosexuality seems far-fetched.
It was based on a vague account that Leonardo left behind, to which Freud found mainly an artistic interpretation. The book is replete with lyricism, so its appeal is understandable.
Nevertheless, the conjectures Freud made are not entirely scientific. Is there a presence of an intimate relationship with the mother and lack of intimacy with a father in a male homosexual?
A summary of the studies pertaining to this question has been included in a book by Fisher and Greenberg. Most of the studies tried to find a correlation between homosexuality and early childhood experiences by using questionnaires.
Braaten and Darling did a study on thirty four homosexual and control samples of college students by using questionnaires and MMPI.
Also, none of the studies examined the cultural component of homosexuality.
Maybe fathers detested or ignored their homosexual sons because society does not approve homosexual tendencies and expects them to react coldly or brutally to it? Still, considering that these are correlational studies, no type of causal link can be inferred about the relationship between homosexuals and their parents.
Does the male homosexual child identify with the mother? Objective evidence in these respects is almost nonexistent.
I found only one study by Chang and Block that shows identification with the mother among male homosexuals. In the study, Chang and Block gave to twenty male homosexuals and twenty controls a list of adjectives and asked them to describe which of them could be attached to the following concepts: They found that homosexuals gave themselves similar adjectives they gave to mothers.
A series of summaries of other studies in Fisher and Greenberg, while focusing on the identification question, looked at the masculinity-femininity dimension. They found that homosexual men are more feminine than heterosexual men.
Even so, there is not enough evidence to substantiate that the score on masculinity-dimension is also a measure of identification. Are homosexual men anally fixated? There is no evidence of anal fixation or anal eroticism.
Conclusions So, most male homosexuals do have hostile relationships with their fathers and intimate relationships with their mothers. But this correlation tells us nothing about the origins of homosexuality.
Can you guess who is the man with the cigar? Leonardo da Vinci and a memory of his childhood.But what this memory of Leonardo states, namely, that a vulture opened the child’s mouth with its tail, sounds so improbable, so fabulous, that another conception which puts an end to the two difficulties with one stroke appeals much more to our judgment.
Leonardo da Vinci and A Memory of His Childhood, is an essay by Sigmund Freud about Leonardo da Vinci's childhood. It consists of a psychoanalytic study of Leonardo's life based on his grupobittia.com provides a psychoanalytical interpretation of Leonardo's The Virgin and Child with St.
Anne. Created Date: 1/13/ PM. In Freud published an essay on the application of psychoanalysis to a case of demonic possession and liberation through exorcism in baroque Austria. For the psychoanalyst working with archival material, it is a matter of rediscovering neurotic ailments under a different rubric.
Apr 30, · His three essays, “Leonardo da Vinci and a Memory of his Childhood,” “Dostoyevsky and Parricide,” and “The Moses of Michelangelo,” examine in a . Leonardo Da Vinci was either the ultimate perfectionist or the ultimate procrastinator, or possibly both.
Following his death, Da Vinci left in his wake many unfinished paintings and notebooks filled with scribbles of inventions he never got around to building.